Reach Us +32 466902141

The influence of music on time and number of steps in the gait of children with cerebral palsy

Carlos Bandeira de Mello Monteiro1, Angela Maria Dias2, Talita Dias da Silva3*, Silvia Regina Pinheiro Malheiros4, Alessandro Hervaldo Nicolai Ré1, Marilia Velardi1, Jorge Alberto de Oliveira5, Marilena do Nascimento6.

1Ph.D. Professor at Escola de Artes, Ciências e Humanidades da Universidade de São Paulo – EACH / USP.

2Physiotherapist, Faculdades Metropolitanas Unidas.

3Ph.D Student at Universidade Federal de São Paulo – UNIFESP. Address: Rua Vitor Meireles, 186 – Jardim Altos de Itaquá – Itaquaquecetuba, SP - CEP: 08598-410.

4Professor at Faculdades Metropolitanas Unidas – FMU.

5Ph.D. Professor at Escola de Educação Física e Esportes da Universidade de São Paulo – EEFE/USP.

6Musictherapist at Espaço Terapêutico de Medicina Integrada Colmeia.

*Corresponding Author:
Talita Dias da Silva
Ph.D Student at Universidade Federal de São Paulo – UNIFESP. Address: Rua Vitor Meireles, 186 – Jardim Altos de Itaquá – Itaquaquecetuba, SP - CEP: 08598-410.
Phone: (05511) 4645-5885.
E-mail: [email protected]
 
Visit for more related articles at Journal of Neurology and Neuroscience

Abstract

Background: It is essential to determine whether music helps in carrying out locomotion activities in children with cerebral palsy (CP). This study aimed to determine whether music influences the locomotion of children with CP.Methods and findings: We measured time and number of steps and verified whether there was a difference in performing the task without singing and singing. The test was performed on eight children: four children with CP and four children who formed the group without CP (control). There was statistical significant difference in percentage change in the performance of singing in comparison to without singing (Kruskal-Wallis test, p <0.05), with the group with CP showing a mean reduction of 19% and 31% in time and number of steps, respectively.Conclusion Only the children with CP had lower time and a fewer number of steps while at the same time walking and singing a song of preference.

Keywords

Physiotherapy, Music, Gait, Cerebral Palsy, Motor Activity.

Introduction

Cerebral palsy (CP) describes a group of permanent disorders of the development of movement and posture, causing activity limitation, that are attributed to non-progressive disturbances that occurred in the developing fetal or infant brain. The motor disorders of cerebral palsy are often accompanied by disturbances of sensation, perception, cognition, communication, and behavior, by epilepsy, and by secondary musculoskeletal problems [14].

CP is characterized as causing various difficulties in the coordination of muscle action, with the resulting inability of the child to maintain posture and execute functional movements [4].

Thus, functional independence, or at least the assessment of development potential that each individual has for mobility, whether transfer or movement, is an important part of the treatment goals of an interdisciplinary team for rehabilitation of the child with CP. Considering functionality, it should be emphasized that human gait is one of the basic components of the independent functioning of the human being, and therefore is an object of study and focus of clinical intervention in many studies in the area of rehabilitation [17, 20].

According to Grahn [7], music is organized in time, having rhythmic beats that occur at predictable and consistent intervals. A network of neural areas, including motor regions, is regularly implicated in basic timing as well as processing of musical rhythm. This quality enables music to be used as a marker of time for physical activity. Rhythmic stimuli control the timing associated with the neural activation of motor movements and these can be enhanced since the rhythm provides suggestions for the predictability of motor movements.

In walking, basic rhythm corresponds to the same sounds in succession, in which the speed of execution may be varied. Children with motor difficulties can benefit from an organized rhythm of music to provide more specific and synchronized movements during the exchange of steps and performance of walking [11].

Thus, this study aimed to determine the influence of music on speed and steps of children with CP.

Method

This study was approved by the Ethics and Research committee of the Universidade Cidade de São Paulo (UNICID) under CAAE - 0002.0.254.186-08 and developed through the signing of free and informed consent signed by legal guardian of the participants.

Case records

The study included eight children divided into two groups: The group with cerebral palsy (GCP) was formed by four children (2 girls and 2 boys) with a medical diagnosis of spastic diplegic-type CP, aged between 6 and 12 years. The group control consisted of four children with no motor impairment, and was matched for sex and gender with GCP.

Inclusion criteria: medical diagnosis with CP spastic diplegia; levels II according to the Gross Motor Function Classification System (GMFCS). The GMFCS was translated into Portuguese by Hiratuk, [8] and classifies children with CP into five levels according to motor function. This means that all the children assessed were able to walk without the aid of mobility devices

Exclusion criteria were: presence of osteoarticularstructured deformities in the hip, knee or ankle; surgery or chemical neuromuscular blocking within six months; other associated diseases; and children with alterations in cognitive functions that would impede in the collaboration and understanding of simple orders in the activities proposed.

Instruments

The assessment used to measure the gait of the individuals was an adaptation of the Timed Up and Go Test (TUG), which measures functional mobility that involves balance, muscle strength of the lower limbs and gait speed. Thus, the child was asked to rise from a chair without using their arms and walk three meters, stop, turn, go back and return sitting, while the time, in seconds, to perform this task is timed [2]. This test was designed by Mathias, Nayac & Isaacs [11] and modified by Podsiadlo and Richardson [13].

Accordingly, the time spent to perform the test is directly associated with the level of functional mobility. Reduced time in testing will indicate individuals as independent in terms of mobility. Individuals who take longer than 14 seconds to perform the test tend to be more dependent in their daily tasks [16, 19].

To enable the application of the test in CP, there was change only in the place of departure. As children have difficulty rising from chairs made for adults, we decided to perform the initial and final position on a bench without armrest, considering the ideal height that the child can remain seated with the legs and thighs flexed 90°.

For this test we used a stopwatch to measure the time to stand and pedometer to count the number of steps. An electronic pedometer is a simple device, a mechanical counter that records the time and the movement of steps in response to vertical acceleration of the bod [12], and to estimate the number of steps taken by recording the vertical oscillations of the bod [5].

Procedure

The TUG test was applied three times to each individual, using the pedometer that was fixed in the region of the left anterior superior iliac crest and recording the time taken to perform the task. Timing ended when the individual acquired the starting position.

After three attempts, the test was repeated again three times, where the individual would have to walk and simultaneously sing a song of their choice and preference throughout the test.

Statistical analysis

We performed a descriptive analysis in each of the groups of the time and number of steps required to complete the task, as well as the percentage change in performance between both situations (singing and without singing). Kruskal-Wallis nonparametric tests were used to assess the differences between the groups and Wilcoxon were used to assess the differences within groups.

Results

Table 1 presents the descriptive data and comparison of the performance between groups. In intergroup comparisons, as expected, control completed the task in less time and with fewer number of steps than GCP in both situations (without singing and singing) (Kruskal-Wallis test, p <0.05). Also, the nonparametric Wilcoxon test found no statistically significant differences in the variables time and number of steps to complete the task when compared to situations without singing and singing. Nonetheless, there was statistically significant difference in percentage change in the performance of singing in comparison to without singing (Kruskal- Wallis test, p <0.05), with GCP, showing a mean reduction of 19% and 31% in time and number of steps, respectively.

jneuro-standard-deviations

Table 1: Means, standard deviations, and ranges for the group with CP (GCP) (n=4) and control (n=4).

Figures 1 and 2 show the analysis of individual performance, where there is a reduction in time (Figure 1) and the number of steps (Figure 2) in all subjects of GCP when performing the singing task.

jneuro-mean-values

Figure 1: Individual mean values of time of task execution.

jneuro-mean-values

Figure 2: Individual mean values of step frequency.

Discussion

It is important to clarify that in the activities of daily living, an individual’s involvement in two tasks simultaneously is common. The ability of dual-task performance (performing two tasks simultaneously) is highly advantageous and a prerequisite for a normal life [1, 6, 9]. The ability to execute and maintain gait while performing simultaneous cognitive, verbal, or motor tasks (dual-tasking) is beneficial in many ways. It is well-documented; however, dualtasking can result in cognitive or motor interference that results in diminished gait performance and impaired secondary task performance [1]. To perform a dual task is key to provide basic functionality on a daily basis and the investigation of the influence of dual tasks in CP is important in the organization of the treatment program.

When learning occurs, both tasks may be performed simultaneously without the loss of one or the other. If the performance of one of the activities is adversely affected, it implies that there was no automation, in which case the action of one of the proposed tasks is compromised. This worsening in functional performance is one of the consequences of dual activity, especially if the activity is new to the performer [15].

A change in motor learning during a dual task, especially when it combines cognitive and motor tasks, can be an important indicator of functional state found in an individual during a health state or during a period of rehabilitation. In the literature, this change is generally referred to as cognitive-motor interference [3].

After a cerebral lesion, cognitive-motor interference may occur, and easily automated activities begin to require a controlled process, with increased attentional demand and greater interference in motor performance, which implies compromise during the performance of dual tasks [18].

For this work, the authors decided to investigate the differences between the task of only walking comparing the influence of dual task (motor and cognitive), where individuals with CP executed walking along with singing a song of their choice. Thus, we chose to evaluate the runtime of the task and number of steps. It is important to note that the hypothesis was that both GCP and control would take more time and would use a greater number of steps in performing the dual task, with control presenting better performance. When analyzing the results, it was determined that GCP had completed the task with increased time when compared to control, but interestingly, GCP performed better considering the runtime of the task and number of steps during the performance of the singing task, apparently, the execution of two concurrent tasks facilitated the performance of GCP. Likely, the motivation factor, due to the use of singing during walking, was beneficial for the improvement of the task. Music has previously been known to mobilize the proposed activity by increasing concentration, where the beat of the music itself coincides with the increased gait of the patient.

Nonetheless, this study provides data that singing aided in performing the task of gait with reduced time and number of steps in individuals with CP. It should be clarified that this study was conducted with four children and that the quality of gait was not assessed. The incentive for further research is important with a larger group of participants to assess whether other factors involved in the mobility of children with CP are emotional, playful or physiological.

Conclusion

This study found as expected that control performed better than GCP. However, the children with CP showed a reduction of time and the number of steps in performing the dual task of gait and singing a song of their choice.

The quality of gait was not assessed, thus, there is incentive for further research with a larger group of participants. Moreover, other studies should verify whether different aspects that can contribute to music (e.g., emotional, playful or physiological) influences the mobility of children with CP.

References

Select your language of interest to view the total content in your interested language

Viewing options

Recommended Conferences
Post your comment

Share This Article

Flyer image
journal indexing image
 

Post your comment

captcha   Reload  Can't read the image? click here to refresh